Catalfino's is proud of the following awards we've won for our pizza.

NAPICS (North American Pizza and Ice Cream Show) Pizza Pizzazz

2006 - 2nd Place - Gourmet (1st place went to Italy!)

2007 - 2nd Place - Traditional

2008 - 2nd Place - Traditional

2009 - 2nd Place - Traditional

Pickerington Lions Club

2000 - Best Crust

2001 - Best Pizza

2003 - Best Pizza

2005 - Best Pizza Lion's Choice

2006 - Best Crust Lion's Choice

2007 - Best Crust Lion's Choice

Slice of Columbus

1998 - 2nd Place - Judge's Award

1999 - 2nd Place - Judge's Award

2000 - 1st Place - Judge's Award

2001 - 1st Place - Judge's Award

2002 - 2nd Place - People's Choice

             2nd Place - Judge's Award

2003 - 1st Place - Judge's Award

2004 - 2nd Place - Judge's Award

2006 - 1st Place - People's Choice

2007 - 1st Place - People's Choice

             2nd Place - Wags & Elliott

2008 - 1st Place - Judge's Award

            1st Place - Wags & Elliott

2009 - 2nd Place - People's Choice

            2nd Place - Wags & Elliott

American Pizza Championships

2009 - Top 10